For this Halloween re-release, Casey Fatchett sits down with Dr. Emily Zarka, host of Monstrum on PBS Digital, to work through a question that started as a Twitter argument: can you actually photograph a vampire? Casey’s theory involves the purity of silver in old photographic processes; Dr. Zarka’s — and the stronger piece of folklore, by her account — is simpler: vampires don’t have souls, so they can’t be captured on film. From there, the two work through an entire taxonomy of monster photographability. Werewolves, mostly human, are fair game. Mummies, depending on Egyptian beliefs about the soul’s fate, are trickier. Zombies depend entirely on which zombie mythology you’re using. It’s a delightfully specific rabbit hole, and it sets up the episode’s real subject: the history of spirit photography.
That history gets genuinely wild. Dr. Zarka walks through the 1860s spiritualist movement and the photographer William Mumler, who produced portraits with the ghostly faces of clients’ deceased relatives hovering behind them — and claimed he had no idea how it happened. He eventually got caught when a man recognized one of the “spirits” in someone else’s photo as his own very-much-alive wife. Even P.T. Barnum got involved, staging a fake “ghost photo” of himself with Lincoln’s spirit specifically to expose the fraud. Mumler stood trial and was acquitted anyway — nobody could prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, exactly how he’d done it.
The conversation turns to why any of this mattered so much to people. Dr. Zarka connects the spiritualist boom to the aftermath of war and mass loss — spirit photographs offered grieving families something tangible, a printed, physical connection to an afterlife they desperately wanted to believe in. She extends the idea further: monster folklore in general often gives people a way to explain human cruelty without having to sit with the idea that ordinary people are capable of it. Werewolves and vampires, in some tellings, are stand-ins for serial killers nobody had the language for yet.
The episode closes on lighter territory — favorite monsters (Zarka’s a lifelong fan of the undead, especially zombies, vampires, and Mothra), favorite monster movies (The Mist, remake included), and the Manananggal, a self-segmenting, blood-sucking creature from Filipino folklore that Zarka calls her favorite non-traditional monster — before wrapping with a genuinely great piece of trivia: how an 18th-century scientist proved bats navigate by sound, using nothing but candle wax earplugs and a lot of patience.
Want to hear more from The Nerdy Photographer Podcast? Be sure to subscribe here on your favorite podcast platform. You can also follow along with us on Instagram between episodes.